Consumers are still spending money, but today’s reports raise questions about where that spending is coming from.
If you walked through a busy airport, attended a sporting event, or tried getting a reservation at a popular restaurant recently, you might conclude the economy is doing just fine.
In many ways, it is.
Layoffs remain relatively low.
People are still traveling.
Restaurants remain busy.
Businesses continue operating and hiring.
On the surface, the economy appears surprisingly resilient.
And yet, today’s reports suggest another story may be developing underneath those headlines.
Reports released this morning showed consumers are still spending money. At the same time, savings rates remain relatively low while inflation continues putting pressure on household budgets.
That raises an interesting question:
If consumers are still spending, where is the money coming from?
Two Economies Existing Side By Side
As discussed in my recent post, Two Economies Continue To Tell Two Different Stories, some economic indicators continue sending very different signals.
The economy can still appear relatively healthy while many consumers simultaneously feel financially stretched.
That may help explain why:
- unemployment remains fairly low
- restaurants remain busy
- travel continues
- and businesses continue operating normally
while consumer sentiment surveys remain historically weak.
One report suggests consumers remain confident enough to keep spending.
Another suggests many consumers remain concerned about inflation, affordability, and their financial future.
Perhaps both are true.
Quiet Financial Decisions May Be Telling The Bigger Story
Personally, I have noticed more cautious financial decisions recently — not panic, but hesitation.
For example, I recently decided to postpone a possible vacation until the fall, figuring flights and travel costs may become less expensive once peak summer demand slows down.
Maybe I am simply becoming more frugal.
But I suspect many others may be making similar decisions.
Families may still be eating out occasionally or attending events while simultaneously delaying:
- appliance upgrades
- home improvements
- landscaping projects
- furniture purchases
- or larger discretionary spending.
My daughter, for example, could probably use a newer refrigerator. The current one still works, but the water dispenser no longer functions. For now, replacing it simply does not feel urgent enough to justify the expense.
That may sound minor, but these kinds of decisions happen across the economy every day.
Lawns still get mowed.
But larger landscaping projects may increasingly wait until right before a home sale instead of simply being done for enjoyment.
Consumers may still appear financially functional on paper.
But underneath, many may quietly feel their financial margin for error shrinking.
Reports have also shown:
- savings rates declining
- credit card balances rising
- and some workers tapping retirement savings to help manage expenses.
Those trends do not necessarily signal economic collapse.
But they may suggest that some households are working harder financially to maintain the same lifestyle they enjoyed a few years ago.
Who Is Driving Consumer Spending?
Another question worth considering is whether consumer spending is increasingly being supported by households with greater financial resources.
Higher-income households generally have:
- larger investment portfolios
- more home equity
- larger retirement accounts
- and greater financial flexibility.
As a result, they may continue spending even when other households become more cautious.
That does not mean the spending is not real.
It simply means the economy may not be experienced equally by everyone.
Strong spending numbers can coexist with financial stress if different groups of consumers are experiencing the economy very differently.
Final Thoughts
Perhaps that is why economic reports can feel so confusing right now.
One report shows consumers spending.
Another shows savings shrinking.
One report shows stable employment.
Another shows growing financial caution.
Maybe both are true.
The economy continues functioning.
But many households may be working harder financially to maintain the same lifestyle they enjoyed a few years ago.
That does not mean the economy is collapsing.
It does suggest that many consumers are becoming more selective about where their money goes.
And that may be one of the most important economic stories unfolding today.
Sources and Related Reading
Related Economic Journal Post
Personal Income and Spending Report
https://www.bea.gov/data/income-saving/personal-income
Inflation Report (Federal Reserve’s Preferred Measure)
https://www.bea.gov/data/personal-consumption-expenditures-price-index
University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment Survey
https://data.sca.isr.umich.edu
Conference Board Consumer Confidence Report
https://www.conference-board.org/topics/consumer-confidence
Thank you for visiting my website. Willie and I appreciate every reader.